Ohio University Kidney Care & Medical Ethics Essay This assignment allows you to explore and critique a system for allocating a scarce medical resource his
Ohio University Kidney Care & Medical Ethics Essay This assignment allows you to explore and critique a system for allocating a scarce medical resource historically. You will evaluate the limitations of allocation in both systems in an effort to apply and critique the ethical criteria for allocating scarce resources at the end of life.
First read Shana Alexanders classic expose from a 1962 issue of Life magazine where she unveils The God Committee, an organization of lay persons in Seattle tasked with determining the lucky few whose lives would be saved by access to the latest technology of the time, the artificial kidney: Medical Miracle and a Moral Burden: They Decide Who. The article begins on page 102.
Follow-up by reading a modern policy on how to allocate scarce but life-saving resources: University of California Daviss policy on allocation of organs for transplant: Donor Selection Criteria
Using the readings from this week, describe in 400 words or less why The God Committee was an unethical approach to allocation of resources. In your answer, try to identify as many aspects of concern as possible, including how the practice contrasts (or doesnt) with modern approaches to organ allocation.
