Barbara Norris Leading Change in General Surgery Unit Case Summary summary the case which is attached, what happen about the case and give your opinion. no

Barbara Norris Leading Change in General Surgery Unit Case Summary summary the case which is attached, what happen about the case and give your opinion. not too professional, just give your feeling. 1.5 to 2 pages Barbara Norris: Leading Change in the General
Surgery Unit
It was 10 PM and Barbara Norris, nurse manager for the large General Surgery Unit (GSU) at
Eastern Massachusetts University Hospital (EMU) sat down at her desk to catch her breath.
She had been on the unit since 6:30 AM but planned to stay for another two hours to help
with the transition from the second to third shift and the orientation of two registered nurses
(RN) from the float pool. It had been one month since she had assumed the nurse manager
role for the troubled unit. During this time she felt, as she did this evening, tired and
As nurse manager she was responsible for managing the staff, scheduling and budget for the
unit. Her 33-person staff included 25 RNs and eight patient care assistants (PCAs). In her first
month as nurse manager she had already lost two RNs and in the six months prior to her
joining the unit three RNs had left. But because of the recently instituted hiring freeze at EMU,
Barbara was not able to replace some of these positions.
The unit was short-staffed; stress levels were high and employee morale low. In fact, GSU had
the lowest employee satisfaction scores and highest employee turnover rate among all of the
departments at EMU. And although its patient satisfaction scores were average, they had
been declining steadily over the past few years. Furthermore, GSU was infamous for its culture
of confrontation, blaming and favoritism. Relationships were tense not only between the
nursing staff but also with many of the unit’s attending physicians.
To make matters worse, over-time could no longer be offered due to additional cost cutting
measures. Hence, if one of her nurses was sick or needed to take personal or vacation time,
Barbara could not offer over-time to her own staff to cover such absences but instead had to
rely on RNs from the general float pool. But because “floaters” were not familiar with the unit,
its specific procedures and care protocols, they more often than not had additional negative
effects on staff dynamics and the quality of patient care.
Nurse Norris
Barbara grew up in a small town in western Massachusetts. Both her mother and grandmother
were nurses, and she developed a deep respect and admiration for the profession at an early
age. By the time she entered high school she knew that she, too, like her mother and
grandmother wanted to be a nurse.
After graduating with honors from the nursing program at Eastern Massachusetts University,
Barbara began work at EMU. She worked in the emergency room for four years and moved to
the trauma unit about one year before becoming pregnant with her first child. For the next
several years she worked part time, one or two shifts per week, had a second child and
concentrated on raising her young family.
Barbara returned full-time to the trauma unit and the profession she loved when her children
were in grade school. When her two daughters entered high school Barbara, too, was ready
for a new challenge and began coursework for a Masters Program in Nursing and Health Care
Administration. Her nurse manager, Betty Nolan, who was a mentor and friend, also
encouraged her to pursue the Masters in Nursing Administration. Shortly after Barbara
completed her program, the nurse manager of EMU’s general surgical unit announced her
Although GSU’s high turnover and low retention rates were common knowledge throughout
the EMU community, Barbara applied for the position in part because she welcomed the
opportunity to stay at EMU but also because she welcomed the challenge to try to turn the
unit around. After a series of interviews with EMU’s nursing director and administrative
leadership, Barbara was offered the job. She consulted with her trusted friend and mentor,
Betty Nolan regarding the position in GSU, and Betty did not hold back or mince words: Do
not take the job, she cautioned. GSU is a lost cause. Spare yourself the grief and aggravation.
Barbara highly valued Betty’s advice but was also looking for a new challenge in her career
and saw the GSU job as an opportunity that was too good to pass.
When Barbara accepted the job, nursing director John Frappewell congratulated her and said ,
you’re doing the right thing, Barb. I’m counting on you to turn this unit around and do it fast.
Barbara thanked him for the vote of confidence but secretly worried that she had taken on
more than she could handle.
Also weighing on her mind was the hard, downward turn the economy had taken right around
the time she accepted the job. All leading indicators suggested recovery was several months if
not years away. EMU’s revenue decreased sharply while costs continued to increase and the
hospital leadership had to make difficult decisions to guide the hospital through the
economic crisis and to help it stay afloat. They enacted a hiring freeze, stopped all over-time
allowance and decreased shift differentials. The administration framed all of these measures
within the context of the crisis and for the greater and longer term good. But an overworked
and stressed staff could not always muster the good will and foresight needed to take the
long view, and tensions were growing in the halls of EMU.
General Surgery Unit (GSU)
The staff in her old organization, the trauma unit, was a close-knit group who worked well
together as a team. Many of the nurses were friends, ate lunch or dinner together and some
also socialized outside of work. There was a helping culture within the unit; a tone set and
finely calibrated by Betty who was respected and well-liked. Betty had earned a reputation as
a responsive manager who acknowledged her staff and sought their input on important
decisions relevant to the unit.
Soon after Barbara began as nurse manager in GSU, she received requests from 29 of the
unit’s staff members for one-on-one meetings and she soon experienced first hand the
culture of conflict and blaming she had heard about. For instance, rather than helping and
mentoring the newer nursing staff, the more senior nurses were often highly critical and
complained about them behind their backs. And many of the unit’s RNs including both new
and more tenured nurses were frustrated with the PCAs and complained that they had
inadequate training and skill sets.
And Barbara also discovered that her predecessor had not kept complete and accurate
records of the staffs’ annual performance reviews. Barbara viewed regular informal check-ins
and the more formal annual review as critical management tools. And she knew through her
own personal experience how open communication and a transparent review system had
contributed to her growth and development.
Barbara decided to run an off-site for her GSU staff. At the very least she hoped to provide a
forum to begin discussion between members of the unit but her larger hope was that the offsite would inspire the beginning of a turn around for the unit.
The Off-Site
Barbara stood in front of her staff that were not on duty and thus able to attend the offsite.
She asked each of them to take a pen and sheet of paper from the basket that was making its
way around the room and to write, anonymously, the 2 to 3 things that most frustrated or
bothered them about the unit. She then collected all the responses and read them one by one
to the group.
Response after response identified lack of collaboration and teamwork, interpersonal and
intergroup conflict, doctors who treated them like order takers rather than care givers,
administrators who cared more about money than patient care, favoritism, dissatisfaction with
staffing levels and performance review procedures… Barbara was blown away by the amount
of negativity; she got more than she bargained for with this exercise.
After she had finished reading all the responses Barbara asked if anyone would like to
comment or follow up. Her request was met with complete silence. She asked again this time
becoming visibly flustered, but still there was no response and just as Barbara was about to
ask again Megan Mahoney a recent nursing school graduate who had been on the unit for
one year jumped to her feet and exclaimed, you people have no idea how mean you are!
During her month on the unit, Barbara observed Megan to be a very bright and affable nurse
who cared deeply about her patients. And in turn Megan seemed to receive a lot of positive
feedback from patients and their families.
Megan was upset with some of the senior nurses. I want to feel like I belong and am a
member of the team, but I often get indirect negative messages and feedback from you. You
make me feel like I am doing everything wrong but won’t address me directly or in a
straightforward manner. Megan then shifted uncomfortably in place and her face flushed as
she continued to speak. One night a few weeks ago, I overheard two of you talking about me
at the desk. She paused and drew a deep breath. You said you were tired of me and all of my
questions and called me a pest! Megan’s face fell with this last sentence; her eyes fixed on the
Just then Jennifer Goodwin stood up. Jennifer had worked on the unit for ten years. Barbara
had noted Jennifer’s strong skill set especially with new technologies and her wonderful
bedside manner. Also, she was one of the few nurses who seemed to go out of her way to
help others on the unit.
Jennifer said, I want feedback. It helps me to be a better nurse and to be a better co-worker,
but the review process here is a mystery! As is the annual salary increase. I’ve heard that we all
receive the same increase regardless of our performance. Is this true? If it is, I don’t think this
is fair.
Jennifer also spoke about how she went above and beyond regarding continuing education
requirements and made it a point to bring herself up to speed on all new technologies,
although this often meant spending hours of her own time in classes and seminars. I do this
because I want to, she said, but I have to admit there’s a part of me that is bothered that I do
not receive any type of acknowledgment whether it be verbal or compensatory for my efforts.
Just as Jennifer sat down Louise Scribner moved to the center of the room. Louise had been
with EMU for 30 years and worked in GSU for 23 of those 30 years. Barbara knew Louise
delivered very good care to patients but noted she was resistant to change, quick to complain
and could come across as abrasive to her co-workers.
Louise opened by remarking, sometimes I feel like I spend more time tending to machines
than I do tending to patients. She then complained about the support asked for by the
younger nurses and PCAs. I don’t have enough time to do my own job, she exclaimed.
Everyday I have to make difficult decisions about what I cannot do for patients. I resent this
because we have too few nurses in the ward and because some of that staff is inexperienced
to boot, I am put in the position of having to pick and choose the care I can give. And after all
isn’t that why we are all here? To take care of our patients?
Barbara had planned for this session to last for one hour but they were now passing the 1 1?2
hour mark. She was trying to find a way to close the session using some kind of positive takeaway. After Louise finished speaking, Barbara stood up and said okay, we have a good
overview of our problems but can anyone offer any solutions?
Once again, there was an uncomfortable silence. In the room Barbara recalled how Betty
involved the nurses in the trauma unit in decisions regarding staffing to great effect. Barbara
said, I do, and smiled. What if, she started, when I’m going to decide on staffing for anything, I
involve you? If you tell me, for example, “We need someone to process paperwork on
Saturday afternoons,” I can immediately bring that back to a staff meeting and say this is what
we have for full time equivalent (FTE). We can either hire a nurse or we can take some of that
money and hire a secretarial assistant. What do you want to do? It’s your choice. This is how
much money we have. We can take a little bit of the nursing FTE and we can hire a secretarial
assistant but we’re going to lose a little nursing time but this is what we have to work with.
And you can help me make the decision. I can do the same thing if we have to cut resources.
At the end of the day Barbara sat alone in the retreat center; everyone else had departed but
she was using these last few moments to reflect on the day’s events. As she worked through
the conversations and revelations, she began to make a list of items that most frustrated or
de-motivated her staff:
Our culture does not value collaboration and teamwork
In GSU you cannot count on others to help you
Our work isn’t acknowledged and our contribution often does not feel valued
Our job is becoming more administration centered rather than patient centered
We do not have enough opportunity to learn and grow
Our performance review system is a mystery and does not seem to actually reward
good performers
Many assignments are given based on relationships and favoritism
We have little input on matters that affect us greatly
We feel no one truly defends our interests or advocates on our behalf
Barbara knew she had to set realistic, attainable goals for each item on the list. Could she talk
to her director of nurses and seek a reprieve from the hiring freeze and get more staff for
GSU? Would regular unit meetings build community and a healthier culture on the unit? She
knew she could institute a fair and transparent review process, but she might not have any
influence regarding making annual salary increases commensurate with a review outcome.
Perhaps there were other forms of acknowledgement she could employ? What should she tell
her boss who was awaiting a status report?

Purchase answer to see full

Homework On Time
Calculate the Price of your PAPER Now
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Why Choose Us

Top quality papers

We always make sure that writers follow all your instructions precisely. You can choose your academic level: high school, college/university or professional, and we will assign a writer who has a respective degree.

Professional academic writers

We have hired a team of professional writers experienced in academic and business writing. Most of them are native speakers and PhD holders able to take care of any assignment you need help with.

Free revisions

If you feel that we missed something, send the order for a free revision. You will have 10 days to send the order for revision after you receive the final paper. You can either do it on your own after signing in to your personal account or by contacting our support.

On-time delivery

All papers are always delivered on time. In case we need more time to master your paper, we may contact you regarding the deadline extension. In case you cannot provide us with more time, a 100% refund is guaranteed.

Original & confidential

We use several checkers to make sure that all papers you receive are plagiarism-free. Our editors carefully go through all in-text citations. We also promise full confidentiality in all our services.

24/7 Customer Support

Our support agents are available 24 hours a day 7 days a week and committed to providing you with the best customer experience. Get in touch whenever you need any assistance.

Try it now!

Calculate the price of your order

Total price:

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

No need to work on your paper at night. Sleep tight, we will cover your back. We offer all kinds of writing services.


Essay Writing Service

You are welcome to choose your academic level and the type of your paper. Our academic experts will gladly help you with essays, case studies, research papers and other assignments.


Admission help & business writing

You can be positive that we will be here 24/7 to help you get accepted to the Master’s program at the TOP-universities or help you get a well-paid position.


Editing your paper

Our academic writers and editors will help you submit a well-structured and organized paper just on time. We will ensure that your final paper is of the highest quality and absolutely free of mistakes.


Revising your paper

Our academic writers and editors will help you with unlimited number of revisions in case you need any customization of your academic papers